Approaching Holidays Marks Saks' Last Days

The Saks Fifth Avenue in Highland Park will close on Dec. 31, which begs the question: What should replace Renaissance Place's anchor store?

The countdown before Christmas and New Year's Eve has officially begun, but the passing days mean more than the approaching end of the holiday season.

It also marks the approaching end of the store that has been anchoring downtown Highland Park's Renaissance Place since it opened years ago: Saks Fifth Avenue.

The store announced in September it would close on Dec. 31. Nearby M Restaurant recently shuttered as well.

Though few details have been revealed about what's next for Renaissance Place, the real estate company that owns it may be considering placing a mix of independently owned boutiques as well as larger national chains in the Saks space. Developers took a similar approach to the old Borders location on Central Avenue.

Some Highland Park residents are excited at the possibilities Saks' closing opens up for reinvigorating this segment of downtown.

"This is an opportunity for Highland Park to help guide the reinvention of the north end of second street, which has always been lackluster," Real estate developer Jon Plotkin said in an email in September. 

The Saks closing means approximately 60 people employed in the Highland Park store will either be offered transfer opportunities or will get separation packages, according to Business Wire.

City Councilman Tony Blumberg wasn't surprised to hear Saks would be closing when the news broke in September. The former plan commissioner spoke out against Renaissance Place, and Saks in particular, before both were built.

"My objection at the time that Renaisance Place was proposed was having a modest mall anchored by a clothing and fashion oriented store, because at that time what was dying in the economy was the clothing industry," Blumberg explained. "That didn't seem terribly farsighted to me."

The Councilman has said, however, that he is more interested in figuring out what to do with the space once Saks closes than wondering if it should have been opened to begin with. He thinks the city has a responsibility to get involved in the process of repurposing the space. Parking in that area of downtown discourages shopping, according to Blumberg and some Patch readers.

"The location on the Northeast corner of Green Bay and Central gets little foot traffic and you have to park in the Garage as there is little street parking within a block of the location," wrote Richard Heineman while discussing the closing of M Restaurant. "This is a terrible spot for a restaurant and not great for retail."

One suggestion Blumberg had was to "put Green Bay Road on a diet," widening the sidewalk all the way to Central Avenue to make the corner more viable. Diagonal parking could be available at the curb. Green Bay Road would become three lanes instead of two, allowing for additional plants and trees, and perhaps some mobile furniture.

"The City Council is constantly debating what we can do to make doing business easier in Highland Park," Blumberg said. "What can be done along Green Bay north of Central Avenue?"

What do you think can be done to improve downtown Highland Park north of Central Avenue? Share your thoughts in the comments.

For more news and updates, "like" us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

AK December 20, 2012 at 03:54 AM
Mr Blumberg, will flea market or call it artists place hurt the prestige of the city as high end North Shore suburb? It will definitety bring the revenues and fill the restaurants. Or are we too fancy for such use?
David Greenberg December 20, 2012 at 04:58 AM
A flea market? Lousy idea because you rely on a ton of foot traffic at those events, and you need a ton of parking to go along with it. Add in the fact that a flea market doesn't tend to deal in the high-end of merchandise (well, unless it's counterfeit, but I digress...) and I don't think it'd be a good fit for Highland Park. If TAC needs more space, let them fund it and build it in the location where they're at now. Maybe add another story or two, but it shouldn't be downtown in a retail sector.
David Greenberg December 20, 2012 at 05:09 AM
Narrowing Green Bay Road to widen a sidewalk is a lousy idea. GBR is a major avenue for traffic and we ought not to fool with it. The street is already challenging enough with the zig-zags, curves, and out-of-place left turn lane at the corner of GBR and Central in the north/southbound directions. Add in the traffic that flows in and out of Sunset and a narrower street is just asking for accidents and backups. The last thing we need is to make it narrower and have less traffic carrying capacity. We've been dealing with the parking issue for as long as I can remember (and that's a pretty long time). There's really no safe way to add more ground-level parking - we've already fooled with the angled spaces and blocked driver's views of traffic in many locations - which is dangerous enough. We need to start putting up above-ground parking decks - the parking lot next to Michaels would be a good beginning. And if we want to enhance the use of that space - allow for an entrance/exit on the ground level for vehicles, but make the parking actually take place up on the 2nd floor and above. Then toss in space for a business or two on the ground level to capture some sales and property tax revenues.
AK December 20, 2012 at 03:58 PM
Lots of lunatics are available in our little town. They demand more parking lots and more office buildings. And absolutely "must have" two story parking "by Michael's". Empty commercial Mcmansions do not bother anyone. Something is very wrong with you people. In fact, city is ready to allow one more development that makes no sense.
David Greenberg December 20, 2012 at 09:58 PM
Why is more parking, closer to businesses it'll serve lunacy?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »