.

Family: Navy Son’s Remains Were Disrespected

Family exhumes son’s body from national cemetery and discovers innards in disarray.

Part 5 of Special Report: Death at Naval Station Great Lakes

Exhuming 22-year-old Kyle Antonacci’s casket, five months after his funeral, was a horrifying experience for his parents Lisa and Al.

“The whole experience was a nightmare, just a nightmare,” Al recalled. But the Antonaccis weren’t satisfied with authorities’ death investigation into how their son Kyle died at Naval Station Great Lakes in Illinois and hired a medical examiner to conduct a second autopsy on his body.
 
They were looking for answers surrounding Kyle’s death. They weren’t expecting to discover problems with the way his remains were buried.
 
“I never in the realm of possibilities ever thought that this would happen. Who does that to a body?” Lisa said, adding that no one would have ever known if they hadn't exhumed Kyle’s remains. “What scares me is how many other mommies didn’t exhume the body to see what happened.”

On Feb. 1, 2010, Kyle Antonacci was found hanging in the closet of his room at Naval Station Great Lakes, which is located 40 miles north of Chicago. The Lake County Coroner’s Office and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) ruled his death a hanging but have not yet ruled it a suicide or homicide. The case has been under investigation for the past 20-months. The Antonaccis claim their son would have never committed suicide. After their investigation discovered suspicious details surrounding his death, they believe he was murdered.

Earlier: More on Kyle’s death investigation.

After autopsied by the Lake County Coroner’s Office, Kyle’s body was prepared for burial by Seguin & Symonds Funeral Home in Highwood, IL., before being shipped back to the Antonaccis in Hicksville, N.Y. He was then buried at Long Island National Cemetery in Farmingdale.

On July 21, 2010, the Antonaccis had Kyle’s casket exhumed and hired Dr. Michael Baden, a former chief medical examiner for New York City and a host of the series “Autopsy” on HBO, to conduct a re-autopsy on his remains. 

During an external examination of Kyle’s body, Baden said in his report the remains seemed to be in satisfactory condition. “The body is very well embalmed and in a very good state of preservation,” Baden added. It wasn’t until the medical examiner cut into Kyle's body that he noticed irregularities.
 
Baden explained that usually after an autopsy all of the deceased’s organs are put into a plastic bag, which is then placed back into the body. That body is then sent to a funeral home for embalming before burial. However, that was not the case when he cut Kyle’s body back open.
 
“The funeral director apparently removed the organs from the usual place in the plastic bag when the body is being reburied after autopsy and added this sticky gelatinous goo that distraughts the organs,” he explained to a videographer who was hired by the Antonaccis to videotape the process. “The organs have been covered with a gel substance that has discolored all the organs and it makes it very much more difficult to examine the organs because they’re all distorted by this gel.”

Click on the video link above to watch part of the exhumation process.

While Funeral Director Irving Symonds would not comment on Kyle’s burial preparations specifically, he told Patch that he’s very thorough during the embalming process and works extremely hard to make sure the bodies “look like themselves.”
 
In addition to the problem with the gel, Baden was also unable to locate Kyle’s hyoid bone during the re-autopsy.
 
“The hyoid bone is more commonly fractured in homicidal strangulation than a suicidal hanging,” Baden explained.

The Antonaccis had been hoping the doctor could re-examine the bone and tell them more about how Kyle died. But because the hyoid bone was missing, he was unable to do so. “It appears to me that the hyoid bone was probably lost when the viscera were emptied from the coroner's plastic bag at the funeral home,” Baden added.

During the time of Kyle’s death, Seguin & Symonds Funeral Home was under contract by Naval Station Great Lakes to prepare soldiers' bodies for burial before being sent home to their families. 

What the Antonaccis didn’t know at the time of Kyle’s death was that a couple years earlier, another military family had filed a complaint with the base about Seguin & Symonds Funeral Home after it prepared their son for burial — information the Antonaccis wished they would have known beforehand.  
 
A New Jersey family filed grievances with the Navy and Illinois Department of Professional Regulations (IDPR) against Symonds in 2009 because of the way their son was embalmed after dying from a heroin overdose at the base. The family told Patch their son’s remains returned home unrecognizable and their local funeral director commented that it was one of the worst conditions he had ever received someone in.
 
But after an investigation, neither the IDPR nor the Navy found fault with Symonds' practices. Instead, military officials claimed circumstance out of their control, like several plane delays — which left the casket sitting on an aircraft for an extended period of time — were to blame for the poor condition.
 
Symonds told Patch that since 2000 his family’s funeral home has prepared more than 75 servicemen for burial and he’s only dealt with those two complaints.

“This has already gone to the state. It’s done. It’s been put to rest,” Symonds said in response to the New Jersey family’s complaint. “I’m very meticulous,” he said about his work at the funeral home, which has been run by members of his family for 30 years. “I have to be for the military.” 
 
The department of Navy & Marine Corps Mortuary Affairs told Patch the New Jersey family’s complaint is the only one its office has ever received concerning remains coming from this particular funeral home.
 
“The process of returning deceased service members to their families is one that we work hard to ensure goes as smoothly as possible. There are times when factors beyond the control of the Navy hinder this process,” a Navy public affairs specialist said in response to Patch’s inquiries. “We extend our condolences to both families as they grieve the loss of their loved ones."
 
Military officials say in order for a contract to be awarded to a particular funeral home there need to be at least 10 deaths per year on a base. Since the number of deaths fell below that threshold at Great Lakes in recent years “the decision was made not to execute the extension of that particular contract,” the Navy’s public affair’s office stated about its contract with Symonds.

While the Antonaccis are thankful to know Symonds is no longer under contract with the Navy base, they reiterate that no one has accepted the blame for what happened to their son’s remains. This is why the Antonaccis say they’ll continue to conduct their own investigation into Kyle’s death and what happened to his body afterwards.

Return to Special Report: Death at Naval Station Great Lakes

Dana Schoppert October 13, 2011 at 02:18 PM
This is not a situation of disrespect. This is a medical examiner that has not knowledge of basic embalming practices in this country. The Gel substance is a normal substance called "Syn-Gel" that is a high concentration of formalin to preservative whatever you put it on. It is used on the any tissue that cannot be injected with embalming fluid and where there is a chance of any leakage out of the body. It is used to coat the internal skin surfaces of the head when the brain is removed as part of the autopsy and the chest and abdomen skin flaps and muscles in those area. This is standard procedure. This funeral home did exactly as they should have done to prepare a body for viewing and burial and in fact went even further than most by using the gel since the most common method is to just put cavity fluid into the bag with the viscera and sew that into the body. As far as the Hyoid-bone they should be checking with the Pathologist that preformed the original autopsy. Many times in a legal case autopsy, there is body tissue and bone that is retained to be studied at a later time or for evidence. This sounds more to me that someone is trying to make the funeral home a scapegoat for an inept medical examiner or at very least a military procedure that is trying to push blame to others to divert blame from themselves.
Tyrone Boyle October 13, 2011 at 07:17 PM
@Dana Schoppert: I would have to respectfully disagree with you. This story reeks of a cover-up. First, this is a case of disrespect for the very fact that somehow all of these pieces to the puzzle have been "conveniently" lost. How does this happen (especially in a criminal investigation!)??? This fact alone shows a clear case of disrespect. The question then becomes who to place the accusation of "disrespect" on - the original coroner who performed the autopsy, the military for not being thorough with procedural protocols, the funeral home who received his body after it was "prepared" and did not report inconsistencies with what is considered a normal set of conditions after receiving a body prepared by another institution? I'll reiterate, the fact that these puzzle pieces have conveniently been lost only sways the evidence that the Navy is covering up something that they should clearly be liable for. This is just my opinion......
john simonivich October 15, 2011 at 12:57 AM
First the sailor was not charged with rape, he was charged with having sex with someone that was substantially incapacitated. The female marine was not drunk, her BAC was .134 after the incident and she had been drinking again before the BAC was taken. She was also a raging alcoholic. She was intimate friends with the sailor she accused of having sex with her while she was passed out. However the piece of evidence that blew the case out of the water at appeals, was a sworn document from a corpsman that proved she was not substantially incapacitated. She lied and threatened Kyle to never bring his name up because she knew the corpsman would tell the truth about her being as oriented as any normal person. A corpsman is a military medic. This medic was shipped to Afghanistan during the process and was never questioned about the incident. Despite the prosecution the defense and NCIS knowing he was a material witness. He was awarded the Purple Heart for his actions while in Afghanistan and was found at 29 Palms marine base in DEC 2010 by attorney James Culp, who he provided a sworn statement to.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »